Skip to content

Are you really self-employed?

Being paid under CIS doesn’t automatically make you self-employed. What matters is how you actually work. If you’re really an employee, you should be paid through PAYE instead.

Signs you’re self-employed

  • You decide how and when you do the work
  • You can send someone else in your place
  • You provide your own tools and equipment
  • You price jobs and can make a loss if a job goes wrong
  • You work for several different contractors

Signs you might be employed

  • Someone else tells you how, when and where to work
  • You must do the work yourself
  • You’re paid by the hour or week whatever happens, including holiday pay
  • You’ve worked for one contractor for a long time, like their other staff

Checking

HMRC has a free online tool, Check Employment Status for Tax, which looks at your situation. If you’re unsure, talk to the contractor and get in touch with our team.

Example

Ryan is a labourer who has worked for one builder every day for two years. The builder tells him where to go, provides all the tools and pays him a fixed day rate. Even though he’s paid under CIS, he’s likely to be an employee.

Disclaimer: This article is based on our understanding of tax law when it was last updated (16 November 2026). Tax rules change and the information above may not apply to your circumstances. You're responsible for meeting your own tax obligations, and you should get independent advice if you're unsure how this applies to you.

Was this article helpful?

Related Articles

Making Tax Simple and Easy

Find out what makes MalgraBooks different to other providers, and why we’re the UK’s most popular provider of accounting software to Self-Employed Slimming World Consultants
Pulse Accounts System
Back To Top